site stats

Shut up and calculate是谁说的

WebAug 9, 2010 · humanino. 2,490. 8. Einstein was not just a dreamer. Doing calculation is not sufficient. "Shut up and calculate" is appropriate to use when there is an imbalance … WebMay 3, 2024 · But for me "shut up and calculate" comes across as a way to prevent discussion on the philosophical implications of QM. Yes interpretations are secondary if all one wants to do is solve a QM problem; however they are primary if one wants to understand what QM tells us about the nature of reality. Jul 23, 2008. #9.

Who was the first to say "Shut up and calculate!"?

WebMost of these do not directly link the two, but about a dozen do. Here are a few: “Shut up and calculate” was a motto of Richard Feynman. For example, there’s Feynman’s “shut up and … WebJan 8, 2014 · The Rad Lab rallying cry of “Get the numbers out” shaded into “Shut up and calculate!” 10 This war-forged pragmatism produced enormously impressive research. on the nature of daylight max richter movie https://digiest-media.com

[0709.4024v1] Shut up and calculate - arXiv.org

WebOct 6, 2024 · Shut up and calculate，这句话的表面含义就是在描述大部分理论物理学研究者的工作状态，比如做高能理论的每天就是列Lagrangian，然后画费曼图，然后算散射截面；做凝聚态理论的每天列Hamitonian，算算基态激发态拓扑相之类的。看上去很高大上的数学 … WebApr 1, 2024 · - really "Shut up and calculate" in mainstream physics isn’t a “command” that relates to only QM, that relates to whole physics for a rather long time and till now, and really now in the ... WebThe phrase is widely believed to have been coined by the great Feynman, known for his irreverence to lofty but empty ideas and thoughts. In fact, it originated in an article by David Mermin, the well known physicist and an author of great repute, which appeared in the journal Physics Today, in its April, 1989 issue: If I were forced to sum up in one sentence … i opened the third door and there she was

Sean Carroll关于“没有人懂量子力学”的说法 - 知乎

Category:Shut up and calculate - 百度文库

Tags:Shut up and calculate是谁说的

Shut up and calculate是谁说的

“Shut Up and Calculate” - Springer

WebAug 21, 2024 · Shut up and calculate. 闭嘴，想好了再说！. 本回答被提问者采纳. 1. 评论. 分享. 举报. 雪花飞舞1213yy. 2024-08-21 · TA获得超过3255个赞. WebSep 25, 2007 · Shut up and calculate. I advocate an extreme "shut-up-and-calculate" approach to physics, where our external physical reality is assumed to be purely …

Shut up and calculate是谁说的

Did you know?

WebApr 23, 2015 · The “shut up and calculate” ethos does not promote this critical attitude toward arguments; philosophy does. What philosophy offers to science, then, is not mystical ideas but meticulous method. WebAug 26, 2013 · If you have a restless intellect, it is very likely that you have played at some point with the idea of investigating the meaning and conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics. It is also probable (albeit not certain) that your intentions have been stopped on their tracks by an encounter with some version of the "Shut up and calculate" command. …

WebFeb 14, 2024 · The latter approach has a long tradition. Already in 1989 Mermin stated [362, 363] “If I were forced to sum up in one sentence what the Copenhagen interpretation says … WebOct 28, 2014 · You do maths after deciding to work out the results. But thinking is the very first action. Shut up and calculate, the way I see it, are 2 different entities. The former …

Webshut up的中文意思就是安静，闭嘴; 关严; 憋，短语shut up是比较常用的，我们要掌握它的中文意思才能很好的运用。. shut up的正确发音是：英 [ʃʌt ʌp] 美 [ʃʌt ʌp]。. shut up什么意 … WebJul 13, 2024 · 卡塔米. 科学的本质就是换更好的电脑. 做物理数年来，时常思考物理哲学问题，有时想不明白，徒增烦恼，有时想得明白，但似乎对工作也没有任何益处。. 近日忆起 …

WebOct 17, 2024 · “Shut Up and Calculate!” is pretty much my unspoken reaction to almost everything I read purporting to be about foundational issues in quantum mechanics. I have in mind in particular discussions of the measurement problem, which often consist of endless natural language text where one struggles to figure out exactly what the author is claiming.

WebOct 3, 2024 · The formidable line up of the 1911 physics conference in Belgium. Left to right standing: Victor Goldschmidt, Max Planck ... it just doesn’t make sense that a particle can be in two places at the same time,” were told to “shut up and calculate”, because the power of quantum mechanics to accurately predict behaviour was ... i opened the letter and there wasWebShut up and calculate. Shut up and calculate∗. Max Tegmark Dept. of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139. I advocate an extreme … on the nature of daylight max richter wikiWeb‘Shut up and calculate’ is usually associated with the Copenhagen interpretation of QM. To my surprise, his argument is not along those lines at all, but rather ‘the universe is a pure mathematical structure.’ I mean, it’s not the most implausible hypothesis I’ve heard today. on the nature of daylight tabsWebNov 6, 2024 · Shut Up and Calculate当然就是青蛙们的实用哲学。. 理想的情况下，应该像鸟们那样做研究，在头脑风暴里，理清正确的物理概念和逻辑，像侦探一样，把所有的证据 … i opened up to someone i realized my mistakeWeb大家应该都知道，如果有人很生气地说“Shut up”，意思就是让对方闭嘴。. 但假如他是很平静地说呢？. 那又是什么意思？. 其实“Shut up”不一定是闭嘴，例：. I won the lottery.我中了彩票。. Shut up！. 真的假的啊！. 这里“shut up”表示惊讶，意思相当于“真的假的 ... iope new air cushion matteWebApr 4, 2016 · As noted, Mermin was probably the first to utter the exact words “Shut up and calculate”. However, the equivalent rallying cry of “Get the numbers out” has its origins … on the nature of daylight scoreWebDec 14, 2024 · ” ——韦斯科夫 5.Shut up and calculate ！ ——David Mermin 这句话似乎常常被认为是费曼说的，还有一个加长版：Talk is cheap, shut up and calculate.David Mermin还专门为此写过一篇文章Could Feynman Have Said this? 论证自己是这句话的原创 ... i opened an llc but never used it